The Court of Justice of the European Union addressed this question on 5 November 2026, in its preliminary ruling C-339/25.
Thomas Derval and Rafaël Jafferali represented Iulicris Recycling SRL in the proceedings before the Court. Iulicris is a Romanian recycling company that invoices scrap metal in US dollars (USD) and makes payments in Romanian lei (RON). The dispute concerns USD–RON FX derivatives sold to Iulicris by a Belgian payment institution. The question in dispute is whether these transactions breached the EU investment services (MiFID) and payment services (PSD) regulatory frameworks.
In its ruling, which departs from the opinion issued by its Advocate General on 19 March 2026, the Court drew a boundary between payment and investment services and issued the following ruling:
“Article 18(1)(a) of [PSD2] must be interpreted as meaning that payment institutions, authorised as payment service providers under that directive, are entitled to offer futures contracts relating to currencies as ancillary services closely related to the provision of payment services. Where those ancillary services are investment services within the meaning of [MiFID II], relating to a financial instrument [in the meaning of the directive], they must satisfy the conditions laid down in Article 2(1)(c) of [MiFID II], as specified in Article 4 of [the Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565]”.
This decision is crucial for payment (and e-money) institutions across Europe and brings key clarifications as to the interactions between the PSD and MiFID frameworks.
Payment and e-money institutions should quickly (re)assess their commercial offerings if they include FX derivatives. Potential ongoing pre-disputes may also be impacted by the European Court’s clarifications.
Get in touch with our team for regulatory advice or assistance with disputes involving MiFID, PSD or derivatives.
***
This newsletter does not constitute legal advice or a legal opinion. Please consult with a legal counsel before taking any action based on the information provided.
